Quick answer: Private schools improve re-enrollment by treating current families as their most important audience: track attrition by grade, survey parents before contracts go out, fix problems early, show families the progress their child has made, and run a clear, friendly re-enrollment campaign with personal follow-up. NAIS members reported a 10.18% average attrition rate in 2024-25.
Key takeaways
- NAIS member schools: average student attrition 10.18%, median 8.10% (2024-25).
- Attrition is usually highest in the youngest grades: 10.3% median in elementary/middle schools vs. 3.8% in upper schools (2017-18).
- Losing a student costs a full year of net tuition plus giving, and a new family must be recruited to replace them.
- Start retention work in the fall, months before contracts go out.
- Measure re-enrollment by grade and by reason for leaving; act on the patterns.
Why does re-enrollment matter so much?
Every family that leaves has to be replaced by a new one, and new families are harder and costlier to find. NAIS Facts at a Glance 2024-25 shows the scale for a typical member school:
| NAIS member school metric, 2024-25 | Value |
|---|---|
| Median enrollment | 364 students |
| Average student attrition rate | 10.18% |
| Median student attrition rate | 8.10% |
| Median inquiries per school | 385 |
| Median newly enrolled students | 79 |
At an 8.1% median, a 364-student school loses roughly 29 students a year. With about 79 new students enrolling, more than a third of each year’s new enrollment is just replacing departures. Reducing attrition is the fastest way to grow net enrollment.
An IES Consulting analysis published by EMA estimated that replacing a single student lost to attrition at a median NAIS day school cost about $19,080, counting lost net tuition and parent giving (2015-16 data). Your own figure will differ, but the math is worth running.
Where does attrition usually happen?
| School type (NAIS, 2017-18) | Median attrition |
|---|---|
| All NAIS member schools | 7.8% |
| Elementary/middle schools | 10.3% |
| Middle/upper schools | 6.8% |
| Upper schools | 3.8% |
Source: NAIS 2019-20 Trendbook via EMA. Transition grades (end of preschool, 5th to 6th, 8th to 9th) are common exit points because families re-decide at those moments. EMA’s 2016 industry report found 36% of schools saw voluntary attrition rise to some extent over three to five years, and another 15% to a significant extent.
What is a re-enrollment marketing calendar?
| When | What to do |
|---|---|
| August-September | Welcome back communications; a short “How is the year going?” pulse survey around week six, especially for new families |
| October-November | Parent satisfaction survey; flag at-risk families; conferences focused on progress |
| December-January | Share year-to-date highlights; preview next year (new programs, teachers, facilities); announce re-enrollment dates and tuition |
| February-March | Re-enrollment campaign: email, text, personal calls; transition-grade events |
| April-May | Personal outreach to families who have not returned contracts; exit interviews |
| June | Analyze results by grade and reason; set next year’s retention goal |
Adjust to your contract timing. The principle is to start early, so families decide based on a full picture of the year rather than one bad week.
What should re-enrollment emails say?
Keep them short, warm and specific. Three examples to adapt:
- Save the date (January): “Next year at [School] starts now. Re-enrollment opens [date]. Here is what is new for [grade] next fall: [two specifics]. Questions? Reply to this email and [name] will answer personally.”
- Opening day (February): “Re-enrollment is open. It takes about five minutes: [link]. Families who complete it by [date] keep their spot. Need to talk about tuition assistance? [Name] can help.”
- Reminder (March): “We have not received [student]’s re-enrollment yet. Is there anything we can help with? [Name] is available this week at [phone].”
Mailchimp’s benchmarks put Education and Training email at a 35.64% average open rate and 3.02% click rate. For re-enrollment, track completion rate, not just opens.
How should you segment families for re-enrollment?
| Segment | Who | What they need |
|---|---|---|
| Committed | Engaged families whose children are thriving | A simple process, clear dates and a thank-you |
| Uncertain | A hard year, money stress, a competing offer, low survey scores | A personal conversation and specific evidence of progress |
| First-year | Families new this year | Proof their expectations were met; a check-in at six weeks and midyear |
| Transition grade | Families moving into a new division next year | A preview of the next division: teachers, schedule, programs |
Send committed families logistics, not sales copy. Spend staff time on uncertain and transition-grade families.
Which warning signs predict a family might leave?
- Low survey scores or no survey response.
- Frequent absences or a sharp grade drop.
- Unpaid balances or a new tuition assistance request.
- A sibling not enrolled, or a move announced.
- Parents who stop attending events or opening email.
- A transition grade coming up.
- A contract returned much later than the family returned it in past years.
Assign an owner for each flagged family: usually a teacher, division head or admissions director who already knows them. A personal conversation in November is worth more than any email in March.
How should schools handle tuition concerns at re-enrollment?
Cost is one of the most common reasons families give for leaving, and many never raise it until the contract deadline. Make the conversation easy:
- Announce next year’s tuition early, with a short explanation of what the increase funds.
- Put tuition assistance deadlines on the same calendar as re-enrollment, and mention them in every re-enrollment email.
- Offer payment plan options and name the person to talk to.
- Train teachers and division heads to refer families with money worries to the business office quickly and kindly.
A family that knows help is available, and how to ask for it, is far less likely to quietly withdraw.
How does marketing support retention?
Retention is a whole-school job, but marketing helps by making progress visible. Share student work, teacher spotlights, alumni outcomes and event recaps regularly in newsletters and social posts current parents actually see. Parents who regularly see what their child is gaining are more likely to stay.
Brandastic’s email and lead nurturing work for California Online Public Schools supported a campaign that generated 3,000 leads a month and 500 enrollees in a November 2026 campaign, surpassed its annual enrollment target by 7+ percent, and earned a 118x return on ad spend (ROAS). The same automation tools that nurture prospects can run re-enrollment reminders and surveys.
How do you measure re-enrollment success?
| Metric | How to calculate |
|---|---|
| Re-enrollment rate | Returning students eligible to return / students eligible to return (exclude graduating grade) |
| Attrition rate | Students who left (excluding graduates) / prior-year enrollment |
| On-time contract rate | Contracts returned by deadline / contracts sent |
| Attrition by grade and reason | From exit interviews and records |
What working with Brandastic costs
Most agencies charge a monthly management fee plus the ad budget you pay Google, Meta or other platforms. Brandastic prices each channel separately, so you only pay for the channels you need.
Channels you can choose from:
Every engagement starts with a first-month discovery and strategy phase. A strong strategy is what makes the campaigns work, so before anything launches we:
- Study your market and the schools you compete with for families.
- Define your ideal target students.
- Identify the ideal target parents to market to and what they care about.
- Build a communication plan: what to say, on which channels, and when.
- Pin down your school’s pain points, such as low inquiries or weak follow-up, and plan how to solve them.
- Decide whether to market locally, nationally or both.
Brandastic fees run $3,500 a month minimum per channel. Ad spend is separate and paid to the platforms. Pricing is subject to change; contact us for a current quote.
Want a quote for your school? Book your free consultation.
Keep reading: Christian school marketing: reaching mission-fit families; How much does private school marketing cost per month?; Open house ads for schools: 497 family inquiries.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good re-enrollment rate for a private school?
Many schools aim for 90% or higher. NAIS members reported a median attrition rate of 8.10% and an average of 10.18% in 2024-25, so a school retaining more than about 92% of eligible students is doing better than the median.
When should re-enrollment start?
Retention starts in the fall with check-ins and surveys. The re-enrollment campaign itself usually opens in January or February, depending on when your contracts go out.
Why do families leave private schools?
Common reasons include cost, relocation, academic or social fit, and transition grades. Exit interviews tell you which reasons apply at your school.
How do you reduce attrition at a private school?
Find at-risk families early, give each one a personal owner, fix fit issues, make progress visible, and be clear about tuition assistance. Track attrition by grade and reason each year.
Should a school offer an early re-enrollment discount?
Some schools offer a small incentive or a waived fee for early contracts. It can improve on-time returns, but it will not fix fit or affordability problems, so pair it with surveys and personal outreach.
Do re-enrollment emails work?
They help, especially with clear deadlines and a real person to reply to. Pair email with text reminders and personal calls for families who have not responded.
Want help keeping more of your families? Book a free consultation. Book your free consultation.
Sources
- NAIS Facts at a Glance 2024-2025 (All NAIS Member Schools; generated Jan 21, 2025), https://www.nais.org/getContentAsset/9bc8aaf6-eef1-4aa7-937e-80e64eff526e/dfc3d011-8f63-43f6-9ed8-4b444333a1d0/Facts-at-a-Glance-2024-2025-(NAIS-Members).pdf?language=en-US
- EMA / NAIS, “Seven Enrollment Trends You Should Know From the 2019-2020 NAIS Trendbook” (Nov 16, 2019), https://www.enrollment.org/articles/seven-enrollment-trends-you-should-know-from-the-2019-2020-nais-trendbook
- Enrollment Management Association (EMA), “Being Intentional About Retention: 3 Steps to Combat Attrition” (Mar 13, 2018), citing EMA’s 2016 State of the Independent School Admission Industry report, https://www.enrollment.org/articles/being-intentional-about-retention-3-steps-to-combat-attrition
- George Conway (IES Consulting) via EMA, “An Ounce of Prevention: How Engagement Survey Data Can Help Reduce Attrition” (Mar 13, 2018), https://www.enrollment.org/articles/an-ounce-of-prevention-how-engagement-survey-data-can-help-reduce-attrition
- Mailchimp, Email Marketing Benchmarks by industry (Education + Training), https://mailchimp.com/resources/email-marketing-benchmarks/
- Brandastic case study: California Online Public Schools (https://brandastic.com/portfolio/california-online-public-schools/)
By Justin Nassie, Founder and CEO of Brandastic. Brandastic is a Costa Mesa, California digital marketing agency founded in 2010 that has worked with 450+ brands and is a Google and Microsoft Partner. Last updated March 15, 2027.