Quick answer: Enrollment yield is the share of accepted students who actually enroll. At NAIS member schools the median was 71.4% in 2024-25, so roughly 3 in 10 accepted families went elsewhere. Schools raise yield by contacting families within a day of acceptance, hosting accepted-family events, answering cost questions early, and assigning a personal contact to every undecided family.

Key takeaways

  • Yield = newly enrolled students / accepted students. NAIS median: 71.4% (2024-25).
  • A median NAIS school had 385 inquiries, 180 applications, 113 acceptances and 79 new enrollments.
  • The weeks between acceptance and the deposit deadline decide yield. Plan them like a campaign.
  • Personal contact beats mass email: assign an owner to every accepted family.
  • Track yield by grade, program and lead source so marketing spend follows enrolled students, not just inquiries.

What does a typical private school admissions funnel look like?

Funnel stage (median NAIS member school, 2024-25) Count Conversion
Inquiries 385 ,
Completed applications 180 46.6% of inquiries
Students accepted 113 66.0% of applications
Newly enrolled students 79 71.4% of acceptances (yield)

Source: NAIS Facts at a Glance 2024-25, all NAIS member schools (1,331 schools). Your numbers will differ, but the shape is common: most of the drop happens between inquiry and application, and the last drop happens after acceptance, when families compare offers.

Each point of yield matters. At 113 acceptances, moving from 71.4% to 80% yield adds about 10 enrolled students without a single extra inquiry.

How do you calculate enrollment yield?

Metric Formula
Yield rate Newly enrolled students / accepted students
Melt Deposited students who do not start in the fall / deposited students
Yield by source Enrolled students from a lead source / accepted students from that source
Days to decision Deposit date minus acceptance date (median)

Calculate yield separately for each entry grade and program. A school with strong kindergarten yield and weak ninth-grade yield has a very different problem than one with low yield everywhere.

What should happen in the six weeks after acceptance?

Timing Action
Day 0-1 Acceptance email plus a personal call or video from the head of school or a teacher
Week 1 Welcome packet: what happens next, deposit deadline, tuition assistance contact
Week 2 Invitation to an accepted-family event or a shadow day
Week 3 Current-parent outreach: an ambassador family calls or texts
Week 4 Answer open questions: transportation, after-care, uniforms, financial aid status
Week 5-6 Personal follow-up with every undecided family before the deadline

In NAIS’s 2024-25 marketing survey, individual tours and group open houses were the most effective admissions touchpoints. For accepted families, the equivalent is a chance to see themselves at the school: a revisit day, a class visit or a student-led tour.

Which messages raise yield?

  • Belonging: show students like theirs, and name the teacher or advisor they will meet.
  • Specifics over slogans: class sizes, schedules, programs available in their child’s grade.
  • Cost clarity: what tuition includes, how assistance and payment plans work, and who to call.
  • Social proof: current parent stories and honest reviews (with permission).
  • Urgency without pressure: a clear deposit date and what happens to the seat after it.

Email remains the backbone: Mailchimp’s benchmarks show 35.64% average open rates and 3.02% click rates for Education and Training senders. Use text messages for event reminders and deadlines, and phone calls for undecided families.

How does digital advertising help yield?

Yield is mostly personal outreach, but ads can help. Retargeting accepted families on Meta and YouTube with student stories keeps the school top of mind while they compare. Use customer lists only where your privacy policy and platform rules allow, and keep the message warm, not salesy.

More importantly, connect your ad platforms to your admissions CRM so you can see which campaigns produce enrolled students, not just inquiries. Brandastic’s campaigns for Heart Christian Academy reported results per campus and per channel (373 Meta and 124 Google inquiries), the starting point for source-level yield analysis (brandastic.com/portfolio/heart-christian-academy/).

Why do accepted families choose another school?

  • Cost or a better financial aid offer elsewhere.
  • A competing school felt like a better fit after a revisit.
  • Slow or impersonal follow-up after acceptance.
  • Unanswered practical questions (transportation, schedules, after-care).
  • A sibling or friend group going elsewhere.
  • A deposit deadline that came before the family had all the information they needed, such as a financial aid decision.

Ask every family that declines. A short, kind survey or a two-minute call will tell you which of these is costing you the most students.

How do you keep deposited families from melting away?

A deposit is not a first day. Families who feel forgotten between spring and fall are the ones most likely to change their minds. Keep the relationship going:

  • Send a welcome note from the student’s future teacher or advisor in May.
  • Invite new families to a summer social or a playground meetup.
  • Pair each new family with a current parent ambassador.
  • Share a simple summer checklist: forms, uniforms, supplies, orientation date.
  • Add new families to the school newsletter right away so they see daily school life.
  • Call any family that misses a form or event; it may be an early warning.

Track melt every year. If it rises, look at what changed in your summer communication.

How should a school report yield to leadership?

Report line Why it matters
Yield by grade and program Shows where seats are being lost
Yield by lead source Shows which marketing produces enrolled students
Declined reasons Points to fixable problems
Cost per enrolled student by channel Ad spend divided by enrolled students from that channel

Channels Brandastic manages

Brandastic plans and runs these channels for schools:

🔍Google pay-per-click
📣Meta
📈SEO
💬Social organic
🤖ChatGPT and AI paid
✉️Email
🖥️Website updates
▶️YouTubeVideo tours and explainers
💼LinkedInReaching school admins
📌PinterestParents planning ahead
🎵TikTokYounger families
📱SMS/text messagingFast follow-up with families

Every engagement starts with a first-month discovery and strategy phase. A strong strategy is what makes the campaigns work, so before anything launches we:

  • Study your market and the schools you compete with for families.
  • Define your ideal target students.
  • Identify the ideal target parents to market to and what they care about.
  • Build a communication plan: what to say, on which channels, and when.
  • Pin down your school’s pain points, such as low inquiries or weak follow-up, and plan how to solve them.
  • Decide whether to market locally, nationally or both.

Keep reading: Re-enrollment marketing: keep the families you have; Open house follow-up: turning RSVPs into applications; Independent school marketing: a 12-month plan.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good enrollment yield for a private school?

NAIS member schools had a median yield of 71.4% in 2024-25 (newly enrolled divided by accepted). Above that is better than the median; very selective or very specialized schools can be much higher.

How do you increase yield in admissions?

Contact accepted families within a day, invite them to an accepted-family event, connect them with current parents, answer cost questions early, and personally follow up with every undecided family before the deadline.

What is the difference between yield and conversion rate?

Yield measures accepted students who enroll. Conversion rate can describe any step of the funnel, such as inquiries to applications (46.6% at the median NAIS school).

What is summer melt?

Students who deposit but do not start in the fall. Keep communicating through the summer with orientation dates, teacher introductions and community events.

When should a school start yield planning?

Before acceptances go out. Write the messages, schedule events, recruit parent ambassadors and assign owners for each accepted family in advance, so outreach can start the day decisions are released.

Can marketing agencies help with yield?

Yes, mostly through tracking, email and text automation, and retargeting. The personal outreach itself should come from the school.

Every school’s plan is different. Book a free consultation and we’ll walk through channels, goals and budget together.

Want to see which campaigns produce enrolled students, not just inquiries? Book your free consultation.

Sources

By Justin Nassie, Founder and CEO of Brandastic. Brandastic is a Costa Mesa, California digital marketing agency founded in 2010 that has worked with 450+ brands and is a Google and Microsoft Partner. Last updated March 3, 2026.