Quick answer: Most colleges do best with a hybrid: keep brand, strategy, campus storytelling and relationships in-house, and hire a higher education marketing firm for specialized, fast-changing work like paid media, SEO, analytics and conversion optimization. In-house teams carry salary and hiring risk; firms add speed and specialist depth. Decide by role, not all-or-nothing.

Key takeaways

  • Median central marketing budgets range from $1.40M at small institutions to $5.10M at large ones (SimpsonScarborough, 2025-26).
  • Staffing is the biggest line: median staffing budgets run $795K (small) to $3.5M (large).
  • More than half of higher ed CMOs reported trouble filling open positions; web, digital and analytics roles are hardest (2024 study).
  • BLS median pay (May 2025): marketing managers $166,790; market research analysts $78,760.
  • Use a firm for specialist, measurable channels; keep brand and campus knowledge inside.

What do colleges spend on marketing teams today?

Institution size (FTE students) Median central marcom budget, 2025 Median staffing budget, 2025
Small (under 4,000) $1.40M $795K
Medium public (4,000-19,999) $1.83M $1.0M
Medium private (4,000-19,999) $3.87M $2.3M
Large (20,000+) $5.10M $3.5M

Source: SimpsonScarborough Higher Ed CMO Study 2025-26 (256 four-year nonprofit institutions). Medium publics average 18 marketing FTEs, compared with 28 at medium privates and 51 at large institutions. Paid media shifted to a 75/25 digital-to-traditional mix in 2025, and admissions offices often control their own media budgets, from a median $72,500 at small institutions to nearly $300,000 at medium and large ones.

Demand is rising too. The National Student Clearinghouse reported total fall 2025 enrollment of 19.4 million, up 1.0%, but private nonprofit four-year enrollment fell 1.6%, so many institutions are competing harder for each student.

How do a firm and an in-house team compare?

Factor In-house team Higher education marketing firm
Cost structure Salaries, benefits, training, tools; fixed Monthly fee or hourly plus ad spend; flexible
Speed to start Months to recruit and onboard Weeks
Specialist depth Limited by headcount Paid search, paid social, SEO, analytics, CRO on one team
Campus knowledge Deep; knows faculty, students and politics Must be learned; needs a strong internal point person
Brand voice Lives with it daily Works from your guidelines
Benchmarks Your institution only Sees results across many clients
Risk Turnover leaves gaps Contract terms; risk of over-reliance
Student data and privacy Easier to keep FERPA-protected records inside Limit access; require data-handling terms in the contract
Accountability Internal reviews Contracted goals and reports

What does an in-house hire really cost?

Role (BLS, May 2025 national median) Median annual pay
Marketing managers $166,790
Advertising and promotions managers $133,660
Market research analysts $78,760

Add benefits, software, training and recruiting time. Higher education salaries are often below these national medians, which is part of why roles are hard to fill: SimpsonScarborough’s 2024 study found more than half of CMOs had trouble filling open positions, with web, digital and analytics roles hardest because of non-competitive salaries, location constraints and remote-work limits. At small schools, the average two open positions equaled 22% of the team.

By comparison, a firm gives you a team of specialists for a fixed scope.

Channels you can choose from:

🔍Google pay-per-click
📣Meta
📈SEO
💬Social organic
🤖ChatGPT and AI paid
✉️Email
🖥️Website updates
▶️YouTubeVideo tours and explainers
💼LinkedInReaching school admins
📌PinterestParents planning ahead
🎵TikTokYounger families
📱SMS/text messagingFast follow-up with families

Every engagement starts with a first-month discovery and strategy phase. A strong strategy is what makes the campaigns work, so before anything launches we:

  • Study your market and the colleges you compete with for students.
  • Define your ideal target students.
  • Identify the ideal target parents to market to and what they care about.
  • Build a communication plan: what to say, on which channels, and when.
  • Pin down your college’s pain points, such as low inquiries or weak follow-up, and plan how to solve them.
  • Decide whether to market locally, nationally or both.

Brandastic fees run $3,500 a month minimum per channel. Ad spend is separate and paid to the platforms. Pricing is subject to change; contact us for a current quote.

Want a quote for your college? Book your free consultation.

Which model fits common situations?

Situation Best fit
Enrollment down and budget tight Hybrid: in-house owns messaging and channels; a firm handles paid media and measurement
New program launch on a short timeline Firm-led campaign with in-house brand approval
Website rebuild or CRM setup Project firm, with handover so staff can run it
Steady social, news and events In-house
Crisis or reputation issue Specialist communications firm working with in-house leadership

When should a college hire a marketing firm?

  • You need results this cycle and cannot wait months to hire.
  • Paid media, SEO or analytics roles keep turning over or sit vacant.
  • A program launch, new market or enrollment dip needs a short-term push.
  • You want outside benchmarks and an honest audit of your current work.
  • Leadership wants enrollment reporting your team does not have time to build.

When is in-house the better choice?

  • Brand, editorial voice and campus storytelling that depend on daily access to people.
  • Internal communications and crisis communications.
  • Work that needs constant approvals across many departments.
  • Steady, high-volume production (for example, a full-time video or social team) where headcount is cheaper than retainers.

What does a hybrid model look like?

Keep in-house Give to a firm
CMO or marketing lead; brand strategy Paid search and paid social management
Content, storytelling, social community Technical SEO, AEO and site performance
Campus relationships and approvals Analytics, CRM tracking and attribution setup
Event and admissions coordination Landing pages and conversion testing

SimpsonScarborough’s 2025-26 playbook recommends modernizing staffing for a digital-first channel mix by “balancing in-house work with external partnerships.” The key is a named internal owner who sets goals and holds the firm accountable.

What questions should leadership ask before deciding?

  • Which enrollment goals are we missing, and which skills would close that gap fastest?
  • Which roles have been vacant or turned over in the last two years?
  • How much of our budget goes to salaries versus media and tools? (SimpsonScarborough’s 2024 study found small-school CMOs spent 50% of their marketing budget on salaries, large schools 66%.)
  • Who on our team would own the relationship with a firm and approve work quickly?
  • Can we connect marketing data to applications and enrollments in our CRM today?
  • What would we stop doing if we added this work in-house?

Write the answers down. They become the scope for a job description or an agency request for proposals.

How do you choose a higher education marketing firm?

  • Ask for education case studies with numbers, and call references.
  • Require that you own ad accounts, analytics, website and data.
  • Agree on goals tied to inquiries, applications and enrollments, not clicks.
  • Get pricing in writing, including how ad spend is billed.
  • Check who actually does the work and how often you will meet.

For a full checklist, see our guide to comparing higher education marketing agencies.

Brandastic in higher education: If you hire a firm, ask what it has built for colleges before. Brandastic’s higher education work includes web design for the University of Southern California (USC).

About the author: Justin Nassie leads Brandastic, an Orange County digital marketing agency he has run for 16 years. He has taught advanced web at Chapman University and has also taught at UC Irvine (UCI).

Keep reading: How to compare higher education marketing agencies; Higher education marketing strategies that fill programs; Content marketing in higher education.

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to hire a marketing firm or an in-house team?

It depends on scope. A single specialist hire can cost more than a firm once salary, benefits and tools are included, and a firm brings several specialists. For steady, high-volume work, in-house is often cheaper. Most colleges mix the two.

What does a higher education marketing firm do?

It plans and runs marketing that brings in prospective students: paid search and social ads, SEO and AI search visibility, websites and landing pages, email and CRM nurturing, and enrollment reporting.

How big are college marketing teams?

In SimpsonScarborough’s 2025-26 study, medium public institutions averaged 18 marketing FTEs, medium privates 28 and large institutions 51. Many small institutions have fewer than 10.

What should stay in-house at a college?

Brand strategy, editorial voice, campus storytelling, internal and crisis communications, and the relationships needed for approvals. Specialized digital channels are the most common work to outsource.

Can a college switch from a firm to in-house later?

Yes, if you own your accounts, data and documentation from day one. Ask the firm to document campaigns, tracking and processes so a future in-house hire can take over without starting from scratch.

How long does it take a marketing firm to show results?

Paid campaigns can produce inquiries within weeks. SEO usually takes several months. Agree on 30, 60 and 90 day milestones at the start.

Not sure which roles to keep in-house? Book a free consultation. Book your free consultation.

Sources

By Justin Nassie, Founder and CEO of Brandastic. Brandastic is a Costa Mesa, California digital marketing agency founded in 2010 that has worked with 450+ brands and is a Google and Microsoft Partner. Last updated March 22, 2027.