Quick answer: To compare higher education marketing agencies, score each one on five things: proof of enrollment results for programs like yours, the channels it actually runs, how it tracks inquiries to enrolled students, who works on your account, and what is included in the fee. Ask every finalist the same questions and compare written answers side by side.
Key takeaways
- Judge agencies on enrollment outcomes (inquiries, applications, starts), not impressions or clicks.
- Ask for program-level case studies with numbers and links you can verify.
- Get the pricing model in writing: retainer, hourly by channel, or percent of media.
- Make sure your college owns its ad accounts, analytics and creative.
- Use the same scorecard for every finalist so the decision is about evidence, not the best pitch.
Why does the choice of agency matter more now?
Competition for students is shifting by sector. In fall 2025, total U.S. postsecondary enrollment grew 1.0% to over 19.4 million students, but undergraduate enrollment fell 1.6% at private nonprofit 4-year colleges and 2.0% at for-profit institutions, while community colleges grew 3.0%. A private college and a community college can face very different years, and your agency needs to plan for yours.
Students also research in more places than before. In RNL’s 2025 E-Expectations survey, 91% of college-bound high school students used college websites, 42% found college websites through a search engine, and 11% used AI tools such as ChatGPT or Perplexity to find a college site. An agency has to work across search, social, email and AI answers, not just one channel.
| Signal | Number | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Total postsecondary enrollment, fall 2025 | 19.4 million (+1.0%) | NSC Research Center |
| Private nonprofit 4-year undergrad enrollment, fall 2025 | -1.6% | NSC Research Center |
| Community college enrollment, fall 2025 | +3.0% | NSC Research Center |
| Students who use college websites | 91% | RNL 2025 E-Expectations |
| Students who find college sites via AI tools | 11% | RNL 2025 E-Expectations |
What types of higher education marketing agencies are there?
Most agencies fall into one of four groups. Knowing which group you are talking to makes it easier to compare proposals fairly.
| Agency type | What it does best | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Full-service education agency | Brand, website, paid media, SEO, email and reporting under one team | Make sure each channel has a real specialist, not a generalist |
| Enrollment or lead-generation specialist | Paid search and social built to drive inquiries for programs | Lead quality and who owns the leads |
| Higher ed consultancy | Research, strategy, brand and positioning | Strategy without execution, or execution handed to a third party |
| General digital agency | Strong channel skills across industries | Learning the academic calendar and enrollment funnel on your budget |
What should you ask every higher education marketing agency?
Send the same list to every finalist and ask for written answers. This makes proposals comparable and exposes vague responses quickly.
- What enrollment results have you delivered for programs like ours? Please share cost per inquiry, inquiry-to-application rate and links to case studies.
- Which channels will you run in the first 90 days, and why those?
- Who will work on our account each week, and what is their education experience?
- How will you connect ad data to our CRM or student information system so we can see applications and starts by source?
- What is included in the monthly fee? How many hours per channel?
- Who owns the ad accounts, analytics, creative and landing pages if we part ways?
- How do you handle compliance reviews for program claims, outcomes and tuition language?
- What happens if results fall short after 90 days?
How do higher education marketing agencies charge?
There are three common pricing models. None is always better; what matters is that you can see exactly what you pay for.
| Model | How it works | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly retainer | Flat fee for a defined scope | Colleges that want predictable budgets |
| Hourly by channel | A set number of hours per channel each month | Colleges that want to start small and add channels |
| Percent of media spend | Fee rises with ad budget | Large media programs; check incentives carefully |
Brandastic prices each channel separately, so you only pay for the channels you need.
Channels you can choose from:
Every engagement starts with a first-month discovery and strategy phase. A strong strategy is what makes the campaigns work, so before anything launches we:
- Study your market and the colleges you compete with for students.
- Define your ideal target students.
- Identify the ideal target parents to market to and what they care about.
- Build a communication plan: what to say, on which channels, and when.
- Pin down your college’s pain points, such as low inquiries or weak follow-up, and plan how to solve them.
- Decide whether to market locally, nationally or both.
Brandastic fees run $3,500 a month minimum per channel. Ad spend is separate and paid to the platforms. Pricing is subject to change; contact us for a current quote.
Want a quote for your college? Book your free consultation.
How do you score agencies side by side?
Use a simple weighted scorecard. Score each agency from 1 to 5 on each line, multiply by the weight, and add it up.
| Criterion | Weight | What a 5 looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Proof of enrollment results | 30% | Program-level case studies with verifiable numbers |
| Tracking to enrollment | 20% | CRM integration plan and source-level reporting |
| Team and education experience | 15% | Named specialists with higher ed work |
| Channel fit | 15% | Plan matches where your students search and scroll |
| Pricing clarity | 10% | Fee, hours and ad spend clearly separated |
| Ownership and exit terms | 10% | You own accounts, data and creative |
Weights are a suggested starting point; adjust them to your priorities.
What proof should a higher ed agency show?
Look for numbers tied to enrollment steps, with links. As one example from our own work in education: for California Online Public Schools, Brandastic generated 3,000 leads a month and 500 enrollees in a November 2026 campaign, surpassed its annual enrollment target by 7+ percent, and earned a 118x return on ad spend (ROAS). The school also reached page 1 in organic search in under 30 days (case study: /portfolio/california-online-public-schools/). For Think Together, an education nonprofit, our recruitment campaigns produced 1,000+ conversions at $26.46 per lead (case study: /portfolio/think-together/). Ask every agency for proof at that level of detail.
Be careful with results that only show traffic, impressions or awards. They may be real, but they do not tell you whether the agency can fill programs.
What red flags should you watch for?
- Guaranteed enrollment numbers with no explanation of how.
- Ad accounts set up under the agency’s name instead of yours.
- Reports that stop at clicks and never mention applications or starts.
- A senior team in the pitch and a junior team on the account.
- Long contracts with no performance review point.
Brandastic in higher education: When you compare agencies, ask for higher education work you can see. Brandastic’s includes web design for the University of Southern California (USC).
About the author: Justin Nassie leads Brandastic, an Orange County digital marketing agency he has run for 16 years. He has taught advanced web at Chapman University and has also taught at UC Irvine (UCI).
Keep reading: Higher education marketing strategies that fill programs; Higher education marketing firm vs. in-house team; Content marketing in higher education.
Frequently asked questions
What is a higher education marketing agency?
A higher education marketing agency helps colleges, universities and continuing-education programs attract and enroll students. Typical services include brand and messaging, websites and landing pages, paid search and social ads, SEO, email and SMS nurturing, and reporting that connects marketing to applications and starts.
How much does a higher education marketing agency cost?
It depends on scope and pricing model. Agencies charge monthly retainers, hourly fees by channel or a percent of media spend. Brandastic fees run $3,500 a month minimum per channel, plus ad spend paid to the platforms.
How many agencies should we interview?
Three to five finalists is usually enough to compare approaches without slowing the decision. Send all of them the same questions and score their written answers with the same scorecard.
Should we use one agency for everything?
One agency simplifies reporting and accountability, but only if it has real specialists for each channel you need. Some colleges keep brand strategy in-house or with a consultancy and hire an agency for paid media and SEO.
How long before we know if an agency is working?
Paid media should show inquiry trends within the first one to three months. SEO and AI search visibility take longer. Agree on 90-day checkpoints with clear metrics such as cost per inquiry and inquiry-to-application rate.
Do higher ed agencies help with AI search?
Good ones do. AI tools often cite clear answer pages, list articles, directories and pages with real data. RNL found 11% of college-bound students already use AI tools to find college websites, so it is worth asking how an agency plans for it.
Comparing agencies for your next enrollment cycle? Book a free consultation with Brandastic. Book your free consultation.
Sources
- National Student Clearinghouse Research Center, Final Fall Enrollment Trends 2025 (Jan 15, 2026), https://nscresearchcenter.org/final-fall-enrollment-trends/
- Ruffalo Noel Levitz (RNL), 2025 E-Expectations Trend Report, https://learn.ruffalonl.com/rs/395-EOG-977/images/2025_E-Expectations_Report.pdf
- Brandastic case studies: CalOPS (https://brandastic.com/portfolio/california-online-public-schools/) and Think Together (https://brandastic.com/portfolio/think-together/)
By Justin Nassie, Founder and CEO of Brandastic. Brandastic is a Costa Mesa, California digital marketing agency founded in 2010 that has worked with 450+ brands and is a Google and Microsoft Partner. Last updated January 25, 2027.